Logan Paul and Nina Agdal Celebrate First Christmas as Parents with Daughter Esmé

Logan Paul and Nina Agdal just celebrated their first Christmas as parents and couldn’t be happier.

Two days after the memorable holiday, the engaged couple shared intimate photos from their festivities on social media as a family of three.

In a joint Instagram post, the parents chronicled their “Paul Family Christmas” by sharing a photo of themselves kissing in front of a Christmas tree.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

Paul, 29, wearing a brown fuzzy sweater with black pants, smiles as he holds their daughter, Esmé Agdal, whose birth was announced in September.

Like her mom, 32, who is wearing a black pinstriped dress with white lace, the newborn is seen wearing her best holiday attire: a red dress with a matching large baby bow headband.

In the second photo, Paul plays outdoor field hockey with his brother, Jake Paul. The image is followed by a picture of the Paul brothers and their father, Greg, posing with baby Esmé in front of the Christmas tree.

Another image shows Paul and Agdal wearing matching tan-colored outfits and making silly poses as they stand in a stone brick pathway surrounded by snow.

Paul also shared a picture of himself inside a home gym during the holiday and showed off his gifts by sharing a photo of him and his fiancée holding a painting while wearing matching green flannel pajamas.

The WWE superstar ended his post by sharing a short clip of himself cradling Esmé on a plane. His dad commented on the post, “Thanks for making it great!! ❤️❤️❤️.”

As for Agdal, she reshared the post on her Instagram Stories and included a sweet picture of herself carrying her daughter in front of a Christmas tree, writing, “I love my little girl so so so so so much🥲.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The couple celebrated their first anniversary in May 2023 and announced they were engaged that July. They revealed they were expanding their family in a joint Instagram post in April, writing, “Another Paul coming this Fall 👶🏼 @ninaagdal.”