3 Editors Put Buffy’s Supima Cotton Sheets to the Test

While each product featured is independently selected by our editors, we may include paid promotion. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission. Read more about our Product Review Guidelines here.

Shopping for bedding is not something you really think about until you’re in the market for an upgrade. Then, you’re met with an overwhelming amount of options. Cotton! Silk! Linen! Thread counts! What does it all mean?

Crafting the right recipe for the perfect sleep includes the sheets you use. Think of them as the base ingredient, if you will, like flour in (nearly) every cookie recipe. Though sheets can feel like a boring or insignificant piece of the pie (I’ll stop with the baking references now, I promise), without it, things just aren’t quite right. If you’ve ever stayed at a hotel, you know just how impactful sheets can be. The right set keeps you cool (hot sleepers, unite), feels soft against your skin, and washes well (because you should be tossing them in the laundry once a week).

If you’re on the hunt for some new bedding, Buffy carries a line of comforters, sheets, duvet covers, and pillows to elevate your sleep situation. The brand recently revamped its Supima Cotton Sheet Set ($128, originally $150), which is made from 100 percent American Supima cotton, a longer type of fiber that results in a softer finish and increased durability.

Three of our editors put the bedding to the test and rated it on a scale of one to five. Ahead, keep reading for our full reviews and find out if the sheets are worth the splurge.